In short

For a big or mixed group, the best Christmas murder mystery game is Broadway Murder Mysteries' Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party: 4 to 20 players, ages 13 and up, one to two hours. For a sit-down dinner of six adults, choose University Games' Mistletoe & Malice. With children aged 8 and up, play CLUE: The Grinch, a holiday theft.

Christmas murder mystery game — A whodunit set in the holiday season and played at home: a party kit that casts guests as suspects, a board game or boxed case solved around a table, or a puzzle book worked through over December.

We earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Commissions never decide which games we pick or their order. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure

At a glance

GamePlayersPlaying timeAgeSetting
Holiday Horror: Murder at the Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party4–20, plus extra detectives1–2 hours13+Office holiday party, ugly sweater contest
Murder Mystery Party: Mistletoe & Malice6About 2 hours18+Christmas Eve at a country inn
CLUE: The Grinch2–6About 60 min8+Whoville at Christmas
Murder Mystery Advent Calendar: The Killer Checked InAdultsOne clue a day, Dec 1–24——
Merry Murdle: 25 Fiendishly Festive Logic PuzzlesSolo, or a group sharing the book25 puzzles at your own pace—Christmas season

Our picks

Best for a big or mixed group

Holiday Horror: Murder at the Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party

The most forgiving guest list of the season: 20 scripted suspect roles with flexible genders cover 4 to 20 players, and late arrivals join as detectives. The publisher rates it for ages 13 and up and says it plays in one to two hours, so it suits an office party or a family Christmas with teens. It is rated easy and puts costumes ahead of clues, so serious solvers may want more.

Best for a sit-down dinner of six adults

Murder Mystery Party: Mistletoe & Malice

A classic University Games dinner party moved to Christmas Eve at a country inn, where the chef is found dead in the kitchen before dessert. The box holds character booklets, invitations, name tags, a planning guide with recipes and host instructions for about two hours of play. It is labeled for six players aged 18 and up, so it fits a small adult table and nothing larger.

Best with children at the table

CLUE: The Grinch

No murder at all: Whoville's residents work out who caught the Grinch, what he took and where. The Op lists it for 2 to 6 players aged 8 and up and about an hour of play, and Character Power Cards add a twist to the classic Clue turns. It is the pick when grandparents and an eight-year-old share the same table.

Best to play through December

Murder Mystery Advent Calendar: The Killer Checked In

A pen-and-paper case that runs from December 1 to Christmas Eve: each day's clue lets you cross names off a 9,600-record hotel register until one suspect remains, and you get one accusation on December 24. It suits a patient solver or a couple who want a few minutes of deduction every evening rather than one big night.

Best for solo sleuthing between parties

Merry Murdle: 25 Fiendishly Festive Logic Puzzles

The Christmas book in G. T. Karber's Murdle series: 25 short festive murder mystery logic puzzles in which Deductive Logico hunts culprits while Santa Claus is missing. It is a book, not a party, so it works on a train, by the fire or passed around the table one case at a time.

What makes a game a Christmas murder mystery

A Christmas murder mystery game is a whodunit dressed for the season. The suspect might be Santa’s replacement, the guests at a Christmas Eve inn or the staff of an office holiday party, and the evening runs like any mystery: everyone gathers facts, compares statements and accuses a culprit before the solution is read.

The season changes three things for the host:

  • The guest list is mixed. A Christmas gathering often brings together grandparents, teenagers and colleagues who have never played a mystery before. The age rating and the number of roles matter more than the plot.
  • The calendar is tight. December evenings fill fast, so a game that needs two weeks of character prep has to be bought early.
  • The mood is light. A holiday mystery should feel like a party, not a crime drama. Every kit below keeps the crime offstage and the story on alibis, secrets and festive puns.

There are four formats, and the one you need depends on your group, not on the story:

FormatPlayersWhat happensExample
Scripted party kit4 to 20Each guest plays a suspect, reads a script or booklet in rounds, then accusesUgly Sweater Office Holiday Party
Dinner party kitAbout 6A small cast of suspects improvises around booklets between coursesMistletoe & Malice
Deduction board game2 to 6Players eliminate suspects, places and objects with cardsCLUE: The Grinch
Puzzle book1 or 2You solve short cases or one long case with a pencilThe Killer Checked In, Merry Murdle

If you are still deciding between a party and a quieter case, our guide to the murder mystery game vs party explains the trade-off.

Choose by group size

Start with the number of people who have actually said yes. A mystery written for six falls apart with nine, and one written for twenty feels empty with five.

  • One or two players. A puzzle book. The Killer Checked In stretches one case across December; Merry Murdle offers 25 short ones. Both are pencil-and-paper, so nothing to set up.
  • Three to six players around a table. A deduction board game such as CLUE: The Grinch, for 2 to 6 players, or a dinner kit built for six such as Mistletoe & Malice if everyone is an adult.
  • Six to twelve guests. A party kit with flexible casting. The Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party has 20 roles, so you cast only the ones you need. Night of Mystery’s downloadable Crime at Christmastime starts with a version for 8 to 12 guests.
  • Twelve to twenty guests or more. The office holiday party kit covers 4 to 20 players and lets extra guests join as detectives. Night of Mystery sells Crime at Christmastime in versions for 15-20 and 20+ guests. Our ranking of murder mystery games for large groups covers the logistics of a crowd.

If your list keeps changing, prefer a kit with optional roles or detective places. Cancellations in December are the rule, not the exception.

Choose by the time you have

Publishers state how long the game itself takes. The evening is always longer.

GamePlaying time statedPlan for the whole evening
CLUE: The GrinchAbout 60 minutes1 to 1.5 hours, two rounds if the children ask for more
Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party1 to 2 hours, depending on group size2.5 to 3 hours with arrivals and food
Mistletoe & MaliceAbout 2 hours3 hours with a sit-down dinner
The Killer Checked InA few minutes a day, December 1 to 24No single evening needed
Merry MurdleOne short puzzle at a timeWhenever you have a quiet moment

For an office party squeezed into a Friday afternoon, the scripted kit is the safest bet: Broadway Murder Mysteries says the kit is playable on Zoom or in person and that the host can play along, and the scripts carry guests who have never played. For a long Christmas Eve dinner, a six-player kit fits the courses.

Choose by the youngest player

Use the age rating the publisher prints on the box, then read the character list yourself before casting a teenager.

  • 8 and up: CLUE: The Grinch. The mystery is a theft in Whoville, the game pieces include the Roast Beast and the Christmas Tree, and nobody dies.
  • 13 and up: the Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party, which the publisher rates for ages 13 and up.
  • 18 and up: Mistletoe & Malice, which University Games labels for six players aged 18 and up.

For a mixed table of parents and teens, our picks of the best mystery games for teens include more options outside the Christmas theme.

Boxed, printable or puzzle book

A boxed kit arrives with everything printed: booklets, invitations, name tags and clues. You open it, cast it and send the invitations. This is the easiest route if you order before the December shipping rush.

A printable game is bought as a download and printed at home. Night of Mystery’s Crime at Christmastime is set at a Bel Air holiday party, comes with a host guide, character sheets, game materials and printable decorations, and is sold in versions sized for your guest count. You print, cut and stuff envelopes, but you can buy it the week before.

A puzzle book needs no host at all. It is the right choice for a solo solver, a couple, or as a quiet activity for the morning after the party.

How to organize a Christmas murder mystery night

The plan below fits any of the party kits. Our full guide to hosting a murder mystery party has the general version, with an hour-by-hour timeline.

Three weeks before. Pick the date and the format, then count confirmed guests. Order a boxed kit now; holiday shipping adds days. Decide whether you, the host, want to play: in most kits you can, as long as you do not read the solution.

Two weeks before. Cast the roles. Give the talkative guests the big parts and the shy ones a role with fewer lines. Send each guest their character and a costume idea with the invitation. Our guide to murder mystery party characters explains how to cast a mixed group.

The week before. Read the host guide once, all the way through. Sort the round materials into envelopes marked by round. If the kit uses audio or video, test it on the speaker or screen you will use. Plan a menu that guests can eat while talking.

On the day. Set out name tags, a pen and a notepad for every guest, and a sealed solution envelope. Keep the decorations seasonal and simple: string lights, a few candles in jars, paper snowflakes. Our murder mystery party costumes guide works with a Christmas theme too, from ugly sweaters to Victorian shawls.

On the night.

  1. Arrival and introductions (20 to 30 minutes). Guests arrive in character and introduce themselves.
  2. The opening. You read the setup or play the recording.
  3. Rounds with food. Most kits run in three rounds. Serve the main course during the first, dessert during the last.
  4. Accusations. Each guest names a culprit and a motive.
  5. The reveal and awards. Read the solution, then hand out prizes for best detective and best sweater.

The way rounds, booklets and the solution fit together is explained in our guide to the murder mystery party script.

Food and drinks for a festive mystery night

A mystery party is a talking party. Choose food that does not need a knife and fork during the rounds: a soup and bread course, a buffet, sliders, a cheese and fruit board, gingerbread and cookies between rounds. Some kits include recipes; University Games puts a planning guide with recipes in the Mistletoe & Malice box.

For drinks, keep the bar off the table. Hot apple cider, cocoa, cranberry punch, sparkling water with orange slices and a pitcher of iced tea work for every age, keep everyone sharp for the accusations and suit teens and adults at the same table. We left out kits built around drinking for that reason.

Keeping it festive, not gruesome

Every kit on this list describes the crime in a sentence and spends the evening on alibis, secrets and timelines. You can keep it that way:

  • Describe the crime in one neutral line, and let the investigation carry the story.
  • No staged crime scene. A sealed envelope and a floor plan are enough.
  • Choose the theme for the youngest guest. A theft in Whoville is as satisfying to solve as a murder when the clues are fair.

Christmas murder mystery or Christmas escape room?

Both are December favorites, but they ask different things of the group. A murder mystery is social: guests play characters, question each other and accuse one suspect. An escape room is a race against puzzles: the group works together to open locks and finish a story.

If your guests would rather solve puzzles together than play a role, look at the best escape room advent calendars, which spread a puzzle story across the 24 days before Christmas, or at our guide to a Christmas escape room at home. The murder mystery party hub gathers every guide for hosts, and our ranking of the best murder mystery party games covers the kits you can play the rest of the year.

Key facts

How we selected these games

We searched Amazon.com on October 30, 2026 for Christmas and holiday murder mystery games in stock, then read each publisher's own description where one was available. We kept games that state their player count, playing time or age rating, and we organized the picks by the group they suit: a crowd, a dinner of six, a family with children, and one or two solvers. We kept one game per format. We left out kits whose story, menu or publisher notes revolve around drinking, kits whose plot leans on graphic detail or on jokes about sensitive subjects, and kits with too little published information to check. We have not hosted these games ourselves: the descriptions come from publishers' pages, retailer listings and the boxes' stated contents. Affiliate commissions do not decide which games appear or their order.

FAQ

What is a good Christmas murder mystery game for a family?

It depends on the youngest player. With children aged 8 and up, CLUE: The Grinch is a holiday theft rather than a murder and plays in about an hour. With teens aged 13 and up, Broadway Murder Mysteries' Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party gives everyone a scripted role and takes 4 to 20 players.

How many people do you need for a Christmas murder mystery?

From one to twenty, depending on the format. Mistletoe & Malice is built for six, the Ugly Sweater Office Holiday Party takes 4 to 20 plus extra detectives, and Night of Mystery sells Crime at Christmastime in versions from 8-12 up to 20+ guests. Puzzle books such as Merry Murdle work solo.

How long does a Christmas murder mystery party last?

Plan on one to three hours of play. Broadway Murder Mysteries gives 1 to 2 hours for its office holiday party, and University Games gives about two hours for Mistletoe & Malice. Add time for arrivals, dinner and the costume photos before the first round.

When should I send Christmas murder mystery invitations?

Two to three weeks ahead in December, when calendars fill fast. Send each guest their character and costume idea with the invitation, and keep the round materials and the solution with you. Confirm numbers a few days before, because most kits are written for a set guest count.

Is there a Christmas murder mystery for two people?

Yes. The Killer Checked In gives one clue a day from December 1 to 24, which suits a couple solving together in the evening, and Merry Murdle's 25 festive logic puzzles can be shared around a table. Party kits, by contrast, need at least four players.

What should I serve at a Christmas murder mystery party?

Food guests can eat while talking: a buffet, a soup and bread course, or finger food between rounds. For drinks, hot apple cider, cocoa, cranberry punch, sparkling water with citrus and pitchers of iced tea keep everyone sharp for the accusations and work for every age.

Sources

Keep investigating